How the displayed footprint is calculated
In the editor, the Map section of the right column shows, under the weight of the map, an estimate in grams of CO₂ equivalent. This page says exactly where that number comes from, what research it relies on, and — most important of all — what it does not say.
Menus are named here as the editor shows them in English.
Read this first: it is an order of magnitude, not a measurement
The figure shown is meant for comparing two maps and for seeing the effect of an author's decision — lighter files, a radio set to By proximity rather than All continuously. It is not meant for declaring an actual footprint, and it must not be quoted as one. The uncertainty of a “per gigabyte” model is counted in factors, not in percent.
1. What the application actually counts
Three quantities go into the calculation. You can see them in the ▤ Statistics window, which opens when you click the footprint line, or through Map › Advanced settings › Usage statistics…. Only online maps are counted: a map kept only on the device is not. The same estimate also appears on each map card in My maps.
| Quantity | How it is obtained |
|---|---|
| Files (MB) | Each time the map is opened, the size of the sounds it loaded, measured by the device. The total adds up every opening, including those where the sounds came from the device's cache: it overestimates what actually traveled over the network. |
| Streams (MB) | Every minute of listening, the number of radios actually playing, counted at about 128 kbit/s per radio (nearly 57 MB per hour). Before any listening, the estimate assumes two radios open on average in By proximity mode, and all of them in All continuously mode. |
| Listening time | Counted by the device, minute by minute, while the sound is playing, then added up by the server. |
Nothing that happens on the listener's device is measured: not its screen, not its processor, not the manufacturing of the hardware. See section 4.
2. The two constants, and where they come from
| Constant | Value used | What it represents |
|---|---|---|
| Energy intensity of the network | 0.03 kWh / GB | The electricity used to carry one gigabyte over a fixed network. |
| Emission factor | 11 g CO₂e / GB | The previous line multiplied by the carbon intensity of electricity. |
| Mobile network | not applied | The display assumes a fixed network (it carries the word “fixed”). On 4G or 5G, count 5 to 10 times more: mobile access uses noticeably more energy per gigabyte than fixed access. |
The two constants do not agree with each other under a French electricity mix
11 ÷ 0.03 ≈ 370 g CO₂e/kWh: that is the order of magnitude of a world electricity mix, not a French one. The French mix is largely nuclear and hydro, around 60 g CO₂e/kWh; on that basis, the same 0.03 kWh/GB would give about 1.8 g CO₂e/GB, that is six times less than what the application shows.
The figure used is therefore deliberately cautious: it assumes an audience spread beyond France. A map listened to only in France emits less than what is shown. We prefer that gap to the opposite one.
3. The research this relies on
- Aslan, J., Mayers, K., Koomey, J. G., France, C. (2018), “Electricity Intensity of Internet Data Transmission: Untangling the Estimates”, Journal of Industrial Ecology, 22(4). The reference systematic review: it shows that published estimates vary by several orders of magnitude depending on the scope chosen, and that the energy intensity of data transmission halves roughly every two years. The order of magnitude of a few hundredths of a kWh per gigabyte comes from it.
- Carbon Trust (2021), “Carbon impact of video streaming”. A study that corrected, with figures, the very high estimates that were going around about video — and that stresses the central point: the consumption of a network depends little on the volume that goes through it.
- International Energy Agency (IEA), tracking report “Data Centres and Data Transmission Networks”. Follows the worldwide consumption of data centers and networks, and explicitly warns against using per-gigabyte ratios.
- ADEME & Arcep (2022-2023), « Évaluation de l'impact environnemental du numérique en France et analyse prospective » (assessment of the environmental impact of digital technology in France, with a forward-looking analysis). The French public reference study; it establishes that the manufacturing of devices by far outweighs everything else in the impact of digital technology, well ahead of data transmission.
- The Shift Project (2018, 2020), « Lean ICT — Pour une sobriété numérique » (Lean ICT — toward digital sobriety), then « Déployer la sobriété numérique » (deploying digital sobriety). Awareness-raising work, some of whose values have been debated since; cited here for the framework, not for the coefficients.
The exact values in these publications change over time, and the energy intensity of networks falls year after year. The two constants above should therefore be reviewed regularly — they age upward, which means they overestimate more and more.
4. What is NOT counted
- The manufacturing of devices — by far the largest item according to ADEME and Arcep. A usage figure that leaves it out cannot claim to be a total footprint.
- The energy used by the listener's device: screen, processor, audio decoding.
- Data centers: only transmission is modeled, not storage or serving.
- The listener's own travel to reach a location-based walk — which can, on its own, exceed everything else by several orders of magnitude.
An honest criticism of the model
A network uses energy mostly when idle: the equipment is switched on whether it is used or not. Assigning a consumption “per gigabyte” therefore spreads a largely fixed cost over variable traffic — useful for comparing, wrong for attributing. A gigabyte saved does not make 11 grams of CO₂ disappear somewhere; it slightly reduces the pressure on equipment that is sized for peak demand.
That is why the line shown in EarMotion carries a ~, and why this page exists.
5. What really changes the footprint of a map
- The weight of the sounds. In the iPad and iPhone app, the Sound version setting (in Settings, the gear wheel), called Sound quality in the iPhone player, downloads a lighter version of heavy maps: stereo or mono instead of eight channels, for example. In the browser, this choice does not exist: the weight depends on the files imported by the author.
- How radios connect (Compose › Radios and streams › Connection mode). By proximity opens a radio only when you enter its zone; All continuously keeps them all open for the whole listening time.
- Listening time, for streams only: a file is downloaded once, a stream is paid for by the minute.
The usage counters of a map: right column › Map › Advanced settings › Usage statistics… (in Edit mode).